Enterprise AI search / evaluation guide
Enterprise AI Search Evaluation Guide
A search answer can sound right and still rely on an outdated policy. Test candidates on your own questions, content, permissions and full operating cost before choosing a platform.
Choose with evidence from your own questions, content and permissions
A sales manager asks which discount policy applies to a renewal. The search assistant returns a confident answer with a link. The link opens, but the document is an old policy. A newer policy applies to this customer, and the discount requires an approval the answer never mentions.
Consider this situation. It captures the decision facing enterprise AI search buyers: can employees reach a supported, current answer and use it within their authority?
Choose a platform by testing that outcome in your own environment. Define the work, compare eligible options on the same evidence, and treat access failures as a reason to stop. A weighted score becomes useful only after the mandatory requirements pass.
This guide considers Glean, Moveworks, Microsoft 365 Copilot Search, Gemini Enterprise, Amazon Quick, Sinequa, and an Elastic solution built for your requirements. Product descriptions reflect primary vendor sources reviewed on October 2, 2026. The evaluation method is KCM's proposed approach. No hands-on benchmark or vendor ranking is presented.
Start with the decision an employee needs to make
Write down a few recurring questions that delay work today. For each, name the person asking, the authoritative source, the acceptable answer, and the consequence of getting it wrong.
“Find the approved renewal policy for this customer and show the required approval” is a useful test. “Improve knowledge discovery” leaves too much open to interpretation.
Separate three outcomes:
- Find: retrieve the right document or record.
- Explain: produce an answer supported by the retrieved evidence.
- Act: change a record, send a message, or start an approval.
Evaluate find and explain first if those are the buying requirements. If actions matter, add a separate test for who can authorize them, what changes, and how the change is recorded. An attractive automation demonstration should not compensate for weak retrieval.
Use the current workflow as the baseline. Count the time needed to find, read, verify, correct, and escalate an answer. Fast text generation is only one part of that task.
Seven options, seven sets of questions to resolve
The observations below describe documented capabilities. The pilot questions are KCM's interpretation of what a buyer should verify. They do not imply that an unmentioned capability is absent from another product.
| Option | What the vendor documents | What your evaluation should resolve |
|---|---|---|
| Glean | Search across connected applications, with organizational context and personalized results. Source: S01 | Can experienced staff and new employees both find the authoritative source? Test the actual content types, permissions, and terminology in each critical connector. |
| Moveworks | A dedicated Enterprise Search application and search inside its AI Assistant use a shared retrieval foundation. Connector paths differ in permission ingestion, capacity, and scoping. Source: S03; Source: S04 | Which connector generation and search surface are included in the proposed deployment? Test the required access rules and content boundaries on that exact configuration. |
| Microsoft 365 Copilot Search | Microsoft's current documentation calls the experience Microsoft Copilot Search. It runs in the Copilot app, searches Microsoft 365 and connected third-party content, and requires an eligible license. Source: S05 | Can the proposed license and connectors cover the important work outside Microsoft 365? Test search results and generated answers separately, including the sources enabled for answers. |
| Gemini Enterprise | Google documents connectors that ingest content into an index or retrieve it through federation, with identity setup governing access. Source: S07; Source: S08 | Which method will each source use? Verify identity mapping, freshness, data handling, and the edition and region in the proposal. |
| Amazon Quick | AWS documents an assistant for work and knowledge integrations with controls at the source, integration, knowledge base, and individual item levels. Source: S09; Source: S10 | Which enterprise plan and integrations supply the evidence? Test search across those sources independently of research, analytics, and action features. |
| Sinequa | The vendor describes enterprise search, multiple retrieval methods, inherited permissions, and choices of on-premises, private cloud, or managed SaaS deployment. Source: S11 | Can the proposed deployment retrieve your specialist terminology and complex documents accurately? Obtain implementation evidence for each critical connector and security requirement. |
| Elastic, as a custom solution | Elastic documents hybrid retrieval combining keyword and vector search. Its content connector security documentation distinguishes connector support and access to indexed documents. Source: S12; Source: S13 | Who will build and operate ingestion, identity filtering, the answer interface, citations, monitoring, and upgrades? Include that ownership and cost in the comparison. |
Shortlist from the required sources, deployment constraints, user workflow, and available operating team. Existing platform investments can make an option worth testing; they do not establish that it will meet the requirement. A custom Elastic solution deserves consideration when control over the application matters and the organization can fund its full lifecycle.
Confirm the commercial package in writing. A feature in documentation may depend on a particular edition, connector, region, release stage, or additional service. In particular, Elastic's documented content connector implementation of document-level security is marked beta and has subscription prerequisites. That status should not be generalized to every Elastic security feature. Source: S14
Build a pilot that can reveal an inconvenient answer
Give shortlisted options the same approved content scope, user roles, and questions. Keep separate questions for setup and final evaluation. If suppliers help tune the pilot, give them the same opportunity and record the assistance required.
Include ordinary questions alongside difficult cases:
- An approved policy and an older, similarly named draft.
- A question requiring evidence from two systems.
- A newly updated document and a deleted document.
- A user who has just lost access to a restricted source.
- A question the approved content cannot answer.
- A document containing irrelevant instructions that the assistant should treat as source text.
Have the business owner define the expected evidence before testing. Review whether each material claim follows from the cited passage and whether the employee can open it. A link to a related document is not enough.
Repeat selected questions in fresh sessions. Record the configuration, source versions, user identity, response, citations, elapsed task time, and any correction. Report results by source and user group so a strong average does not conceal a missing department.
Keep access controls outside the weighted score
Create a separate decision to proceed or hold for mandatory requirements. These can include access boundaries, approved data handling, critical source coverage, acceptable content freshness, and required audit evidence.
For access testing, inspect titles, snippets, answers, citations, and downloadable outputs as well as the destination document. Blocking a document after its confidential text has appeared in an answer is too late.
Test content updates and permission changes on separate clocks. A document may be current while access membership is stale. Agree the required revocation behaviour with the security owner before the pilot. If there is a propagation delay, decide how the affected content will be contained during that interval.
Inherited permissions also need review. A search system can faithfully reproduce an overly broad source permission. Fix that source configuration before declaring the information safe to expose more widely through search.
Passing a finite test suite gives evidence about the tested configuration. It does not prove that every future query or access change is safe.
Use a scorecard to make tradeoffs visible
Set weights and rating rules before seeing results. This starting model totals 100 points; adapt it to the business decision.
| Dimension | Weight | Evidence to inspect |
|---|---|---|
| Answer and retrieval quality | 30 | Correct evidence, supported answers, handling of missing or conflicting information |
| Source coverage and freshness | 20 | Critical and secondary sources, usable content types, observed update and deletion behaviour |
| Employee workflow | 15 | Completed tasks, verification effort, adoption barriers, accessibility |
| Operations and governance | 15 | Monitoring, failure diagnosis, administrative effort, support, change and exit procedures |
| Total cost and value | 20 | Comparable implementation and operating estimates, measured task improvement, sensitivity to adoption and usage |
Rate each dimension from zero to five. Zero means absent or untested; one means documentation only; two means demonstrated; three means partly verified in the pilot; four means the agreed target is met; five means a predefined stretch target is met. Attach the evidence and record any unmet target. If the target is mandatory, a rating of three cannot clear the gate.
Calculate each contribution as weight × rating ÷ 5, then add the contributions. Keep security failures and other mandatory gaps visible next to the total. Do not turn them into small deductions.
A worked decision
Suppose three configurations receive the following ratings. They do not represent any of the seven vendors.
| Dimension | Weight | Candidate A | Candidate B | Candidate C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Answer and retrieval quality | 30 | 4 | 4 | 5 |
| Source coverage and freshness | 20 | 4 | 3 | 4 |
| Employee workflow | 15 | 4 | 3 | 4 |
| Operations and governance | 15 | 3 | 4 | 3 |
| Total cost and value | 20 | 3 | 4 | 4 |
| Weighted total, out of 100 | 100 | 73 | 73 | 83 |
| Mandatory requirements | Pass in tested scope | Pass in tested scope | Hold: restricted content exposed |
Candidate C's 83 does not justify release. A and B remain tied, with different unresolved targets. The next useful step is to test A's support effort and B's secondary-source coverage and workflow friction. Buying the highest number would ignore the most consequential finding.
The companion eGuide expands this example into a repeatable test set, scorecard, acceptance record, and cost worksheet. The example counts, thresholds and results are inputs to the worked decision, not measured vendor results.
Compare the cost of a working service
Ask every supplier, and the internal build team, to price the same user population, sources, volume, support expectations, and evaluation scope. Include setup, content preparation, connector work, platform charges, model usage where relevant, monitoring, security reviews, training, and ongoing ownership. Include migration and exit work too.
Report existing committed spending separately from the incremental decision cost. Treat employee capacity released by faster work separately from cash savings. Time becomes financial benefit only through an explicit use of that capacity or an actual reduction in spending.
A modest pilot can establish whether the decision is ready. It cannot support a productivity claim across the enterprise without further evidence.
Make the next decision small enough to verify
Before a vendor demonstration, agree three things: the business questions that matter, the evidence a successful answer must contain, and the conditions that would stop the rollout. Use those to select a bounded pilot and an accountable owner.
KCM can help your team define the evaluation, examine data and access readiness, and turn findings into a practical implementation decision.
Discuss your enterprise AI search evaluation with KCM.
Primary sources
Product descriptions are attributed to these primary sources, checked 2026-10-02. The evaluation method is KCM's proposed approach.
- S01 Glean: About Glean Search
- S02 Glean: Access verification
- S03 Moveworks: Enterprise Search Overview
- S04 Moveworks: Search Connectors
- S05 Microsoft: Microsoft Copilot Search
- S06 Microsoft: Microsoft Copilot Search frequently asked questions
- S07 Google: Introduction to connectors and data stores
- S08 Google: Configure identity provider
- S09 AWS: Amazon Quick
- S10 AWS: Data access integrations
- S11 Sinequa: Enterprise Agentic AI Platform
- S12 Elastic: Hybrid search
- S13 Elastic: Connectors security
- S14 Elastic: Document level security for content connectors
Ready to evaluate search on your real workflows?

